The story’s central theme – memory and perspective – has been much more insightfully investigated by Charlie Kaufman in both Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind and Synecdoche, New York.
While perhaps a touch overlong and with plot strands that don't hang together as well as they might, this is remains a triumph, illuminated by a terrific leading man turn from Paul Giamatti.
If there's a reason to see Barney's Version, it's Giamatti, who does noble missionary work on behalf of boozy, womanising paunchy misanthropes. Barney may sound aggravating, but I've read the book and, believe me, he's nicer in this film.
The life of a guy who constantly screws up could be a downer. But Barney’s Version is a heart-toasting pleasure thanks not least to a trio of engrossing performances.
This is a US Calvary, its emotional-crucifixion tales charging toward us with flashing brass and waving sabres.
This a refreshingly idiosyncratic drama, rambling and self-absorbed, but also smart and literate.
However much you want to like it there's something crucial missing, and it's as straightforward and complex as this: a believable impression of lived experience.
Fine acting can't redeem plodding tale.
It's all as warm and fuzzy as the smoke from Barney's cigars, and just as much of an acquired taste.
Every scene will make you smile.
Giamatti was ready for a part that showed what a versatile performer he can be, and Barney is that role. You may not always like Barney the character, but you will always be interested in him.
Feels rather like its antihero: inadequate.
Having spent an hour showing us that he's a walking disaster it's disappointing to be told that we should get out our hankies, because he's actually a misunderstood saint.
It's an immensely engaging picture about a flawed mensch.
Paul Giamatti
Interview: Paul Giamatti, actor--'It's a bummer to have people think you're a psychopath...'
Paul Giamatti: not just a funny face
Rosamund Pike: 'I seek adventure all the time'
Rosamund Pike laughs in the face of romantic disappointment
Did Barney need another version?
Paul Giamatti, actor
General release. Check local listings for show times.
RSS feed of Cinema reviews